I can't really do a "Best and Worst" for Pokemon because I'm not far enough into the weeds with the intricacies of the series and how everything works. Not a Poke-pro or anything. What I can do is rank the series. This is based on my personal enjoyment of each one, having played all of them at least once. Their placement is also affected by how relevant they are today; a lot of these are pretty obsolete now. So be prepared to see some really good games getting ranked surprisingly low just because they've been completely surpassed by better versions.
#23. Pokemon Diamond / Pearl (Gen 4) - Well, somebody had to be the worst. This game is as slow as molasses. It was my return to the series for the first time since Gen 1, and it nearly warded me right back off of the series forever. Every battle takes much longer than it should, with constant emotes for things like the weather just using up time.
A lot of people have a soft spot for Sinnoh, but I'm sorry, it was awful. If one wants to revisit this gen, go for Platinum. Which, ironically, sold half as much as these versions did. These were the two best-selling games on the DS, which I attribute entirely to them being the first Pokemon games on there and riding the high set by Gen 3 and the Gen 1 remakes on the GBA. Aside from the speed being such an issue, the game just didn't really do anything new.
#22. Pokemon Brilliant Diamond / Shining Pearl (Gen 4 Remake) - This came along just in time for when people were feeling Sinnoh nostalgia...and proceeded to serve up a big lump of coal. Most of the issue here is the visuals. Much like the speed of the previous game(s), it was one big design choice that just tanked everything else. This would have been a lot better recieved if it has the same normal-proportioned graphic style as Let's Go Pikachu. Or ORAS. Or Sword/Shield. Or anything else that came before this absolute regression. If they remake Gen 5, hopefully they go back to the visual style of the Gen 3 remake and not this one.
#21. Pokemon Legends: Z-A (Gen 6 Spinoff) - This is notable because you can make a pretty gorgeous character in it, and it contains all sorts of dress-up options. People into that will have fun, people not into it will hate it. I wish Pokemon Scarlett/Violet had the dress-up options that this game did, instead of the collection of gender-neutral poofy pants and nerd goggles that it gives you as appearance options. Even the DLC for that game, which adds a bunch of new outfits, still only gives you a bunch of lame as hell choices. This game, on the other hand... some terrific outfits. If Gen 9 had the customization that this game does, it would fix that game's biggest weakness.
Well, I've avoided talking about THIS game long enough. Didn't like it. Outside of the outfits and customization, it's one of the worst games in the series. You're limited to exploring a city, which isn't very big, and where every area largely looks the same. The boss fights are basically an action game, and the final chapters of the game are just a nonstop series of boring fights that drag on. The only part of the game that I particularly liked was the one park late in the game where it was snowing. Only in that one area, not the rest of the city. It was the closest thing to actually going somewhere that wasn't the same ol' city environment. This had some solid fundamentals that just needed to be in a different game.
#20. Pokemon X / Y (Gen 6) - I've made no bones that Gen 6 is my least-favorite generation, and it really shouldn't be. Desperately needed a Z that improved on it the way Platinum did for its gen. They finally added party EXP sharing here, and jump the series from 2D to 3D. Lots of new QOL and it's a good-looking game. Biggest problem here is how ridiculously easy it is. Once again, one major design choice just drags everything else down.
You basically have to try to lose to ever have any real chance of losing in this game. There's maybe one gym leader in the game that poses any real threat to you (IIRC the second or third gym) and that's about it. The game tells you what moves are super effective and which aren't, at all times, so you don't need to remember types or even think much. Types matter less than ever, too, since everything is so easy regardless of what you use. The setting, Kalos (France) was the main positive about this generation, but other than that, it's the worst for me bar none.
#19. Pokemon Green / Red (Gen 0) - Generation Zero, basically. The Japan-only first round of Pokemon. It's a good first attempt, and doesn't do anything aggressively badly or anything. However, it's full of glitches and bugs, and the gameplay is more random than anything else. Enemy turns seem like they have a 25% chance of using each of their moves, so it's mostly a matter of having luck that they don't spam their good moves. This is the only reason I was able to beat the game with a 20 level deficit versus the final boss, as seen above.
Some of the Pokemon are completely overpowered; Psychic types have no weaknesses at all at this point and do super effective damage against a lot of others. Water types also don't seem to have working vulnerabilities in a lot of cases. Just a lot of weird stuff. Critical hits run off of Speed, so a high-speed 'mon like Sandslash is completely overpowered. His Slash attack, with a high critical rate, essentially criticals close to 100% of the time in this game and allows you to pretty much solo the game with him. So yeah, it's a wildly unbalanced, and buggy, game. It started all this, though. Pokemon Blue is the upgrade to these, and the U.S. version of Pokemon Red is based on that game rather than the actual original Japan one I'm talking about here.
#18. Pokemon Blue / Red (Gen 1) - Here's Blue, the upgrade version, which came to the US and got a new version of Red along with it. Not as good as people remember. Obsoleted by Pokemon Yellow. Further, completely obsoleted by FireRed/LeafGreen. While it's better than the original Green/Red, this version is still very glitchy and very slow. No shared EXP. No running shoes. No quality of life. NO RUNNING SHOES. You gotta walk everywhere in this game! It's just so obsolete at this point. It's such a groundbreaking classic that most people would rank it a lot higher. Most people also haven't tried to play it lately. It's still a good game, the first game on this list that I consider to still be worth playing. Gen 1 just has much better ways to play it now.
#17. Pokemon Yellow (Gen 1) - Would be ranked higher if FireRed/LeafGreen didn't exist. It's just as good as Blue/Red, only with Pikachu as a starter and some various cosmetic improvements. Pikachu doesn't work as well as the original starter trio, and struggles on some of the early boss fights. The coolness of having him follow you around on the overworld can't be beat, though. While this was obsoleted by Let's Go Pikachu later on, it's still a classic.
#16. Pokemon Gold / Silver (Gen 2) - Some of the same issues go for these as Blue/Red, though they're better games. They're super slow, and obsoleted by better versions. Don't remember them getting as much attention as they deserved back in 2000 when they dropped; me and most people I know were busy with the Playstation by then. They have a great pair of legendaries. If Pokemon Crystal didn't exist, this would be a few spots higher. However, that version makes these redundant for anyone except series completionists. The main issue with this game, besides lack of Running Shoes, is that without shared EXP your 'mons gain levels very slowly. By the lategame, boss fights tend to far outpace your party on levels, especially the last couple of optional bosses. Having to level grind a lot more than you should is the thing that brings Gen 2 down.
#15. Pokemon Legends: Arceus (Gen 4 Spinoff) - Speaking of grinding, this is grinding: the game. Just a lot of going around grinding the same objectives over and over again to fill out checklists. Really not sure why this game gets so much praise. It tries new things, yeah, but it's full of empty space, requires a ton of tedious grinding, and everything good that it does, Scarlet/Violet improves on. Matter of fact this game feels almost like a beta test game for Gen 9...which should have gotten all the credit that this game did. While that game has an open world packed with activities, this game has a big empty open world with dull, boring environments. It's fundamentally solid, at least, and tries something new, which counts for a lot.
#14. Pokemon Ruby / Sapphire (Gen 3) - The beginnings of Diamond/Pearl's slowness can be found here, and I don't really think Gen 3 does anything exceedingly well compared to the rest of the series. It's pretty much right in the middle, a solid average. Steven is probably the second-most interesting Pokemon Champion in the series behind Cynthia. The amount of HMs had gotten pretty absurd by this point, and it's another game obsoleted by later versions, so I can't place it too high.
#13. Pokemon: Let's Go Pikachu / Let's Go Eevee (Gen 1 Super Remake) - Another baby mode game with no difficulty, like Gen 6, this made the terrible mistake of doing away with random battles so that it could incorporate a Pokemon Go minigame and capitalize on all the hype for that game. This makes the game pretty tedious to play. The boss fights are the only time the game really requires anything out of the player, and with all the moves labeled as to their effectiveness, you never need to actually make an effort. Also, your starter (either Pikachu or Eevee) is insanely overpowered in this version. Pikachu for example gets one move early on that always goes first and always criticals, and can solo the game with that. Boring.
So why isn't it lower? Because it's so damn charming! Having Pikachu (or any other 'mon) follow you around makes this the best version of Pokemon Yellow, basically. Eevee is cool too. Worth noting that both Pikachu and Eevee don't evolve in these games, and are in enhanced versions of their base forms. Will we ever see a Gen 2 super remake in this style? It's the one gen left (well, besides 5) that has never had a 3D version.
#12. Pokemon Crystal (Gen 2) - This is a huge improvement on Gold/Silver. Notable for being the first time you could make a female character. Obsoletes the previous Gen 2 releases and lets you capture all of the legendaries for this gen inside of one game. All of the Kanto stuff, which is technically postgame but not really, adds SO MUCH to Johto. That stuff was all in Gold/Silver, but here it's fully realized and fleshed-out with all of the content from both games. Probably the first great Pokemon game, and the only downside to it is that the leveling curve is still wonked. You usually reach the endgame significantly lower-level than you need to be, for whatever reason. The game desperately needs shared group EXP. It also has the iconic postgame fight with the main character from Gen 1. Lots to like here.
#11. Pokemon AlphaSapphire / OmegaRuby (Gen 3 Remake) - After Gen 6 was a miss with a lot of fans, the time was ripe for a nostalgic return to Gen 3. Ten years on, people had enough time to miss the Gen 3 they grew up with, and this was a game that leveraged that nostalgia to its full extent. Personally I didn't like this as much as Emerald because this came out during Gen 6 and took the worst aspect of X/Y: Babymode Difficulty. Indeed, this game is mind bogglingly easy, and that's what prevents it from being the definitive version of Gen 3 despite being a very nice remake.
And yeah, it's a lot better than the Gen 4 remake that followed it; not sure why that game didn't follow in the footsteps of this one more. Lastly, this remake added the "Episode Delta" postgame chapter that would have been a paid DLC in any of the later games, and was a tremendous addition to Gen 3. Especially considering it's free. Alas, this was the last real era of postgame additions being free, before the console era and advent of DLC began in this series.
#10. Pokemon Sword / Shield (Gen 8) - I can hear the mutters of blasphemy already at this gen being placed so high. Gen 8 goes to England for the first time ever and feels like the first true full fledged console generation of Pokemon. There's a lot to like here and I do. The boss music here is probably the best battle track in the entire series. Unfortunately they, as usual, made several major design choices that brought the game down. This generation is insanely easy, almost as easy as Gen 6 or Let's Go Pikachu. You can steamroll the game with a little bit of leveling, and you don't even need to remember or learn enemy types and weaknesses because the game always just tells you what to use. You can sleepwalk through these battles as a result.
The big gimmick here is Dynamax, and everyone ingame makes this big deal about Dynamax. Well, I think it's more like Dynasucks! It makes a Pokemon get big, whoop de doo. The boss fights are awesome until everyone in the crowd starts chanting for Dynamax and the last round turns into a lame slugfest. All of that said...I really like this game, I like the look of it, and it feels like the first true "next generation" of Pokemon in a long time. It also has a couple of pretty decent DLC areas that are fun and add some nice legendaries. They break the game if you go to them early, though. They're better treated as postgame.
#9. Pokemon Sun / Moon (Gen 7) - Hawaii is the setting here, and this is the most open-world Gen in the series besides Gen 9. I really liked being able to tackle the various islands in different orders. The next entry obsoletes this in pretty much every regard with a litany of small improvements. There is one thing this game does better, though. The story is a little better here, and there were a couple of good scenes that got inexplicably taken out of the next version. So this and the next are pretty much a statistical tie, and this isn't entirely obsoleted by its improved version like so many others are.
#8. Pokemon Ultra Sun / Ultra Moon (Gen 7) - Not a deluxe version, not a remake, not a spinoff...just sort of an enhanced/finished version. A "second draft" if you will. I'd have rather seen them skip Sun/Moon and just put this out a year later as the finished Gen 7. Chances are Gen 7 would be more well-regarded if they did that. That said, a lot of folks like Sun/Moon more, because it includes some story parts that got omitted from this game for whatever reason. Everything else got improved though...I think. A lot of folks differ on this one and how necessary it actually was for them to even make these Ultra versions. Like I said, these probably should have just been the sole Gen 7 game(s), and had all of the story scenes included. This also deserves credit for adding a new postgame chapter that brings back Ghetsis, the villain of Gen 5.
#7. Pokemon Emerald (Gen 3) - Obsoletes the previous Ruby/Sapphire by essentially combining them into one big game. It's pretty awesome. Wallace is a much worse champion / final boss than Steven in the regular versions of Gen 3, but other than that this game is on another level from them. Both of the two enemy teams, and their accompanying storylines, are found here. It goes well beyond the usual deluxe versions.
It also introduces a robust postgame that became the standard in Pokemon games after this, with a bunch of challenge modes that give you endless testing and refinement for your team in the postgame. Gen 3 is a bit rocky, and I don't like the look of it as much as some of the others, but they really landed the plane right with Emerald. Still the best way to play Gen 3, edging out even the remake.
#6. Pokemon Scarlet / Violet (Gen 9) - Gen 9 needs the caveat that I'm ranking it based on the current Switch 2 version, which fixes most of the graphics and framerate issues. When this game first came out, it definitely had serious problems on a technical level, mostly due to how antiquated the Switch actually was. It's a lot better now. The main issue at this point is how lame most of the player character outfits look. Poofy pants and goggles abound in this gender-neutral outfit hellscape. Meanwhile the NPCs get to have all kinds of nice outfits that often make said random NPCs infinitely more appealing than your player character.
All of that said, this game takes the open world concepts introduced in Pokemon Legends: Arceus and gives it a far more detailed map brimming with things to do. This is pretty much the Elden Ring of Pokemon games: Run in any direction, find things to do. There are several main storylines to follow, gym leaders to fight, dungeons to do, and so on. You can skip things and go back to them later. You can try higher level things early if you feel like it. You can do the gyms in backwards order.
The only real downside to all of this is that you frequently run into things that you can't handle yet, because there are no rails guiding you on where you should be going. It doesn't divide the world into a bunch of sub-worlds with their own appropriate level ranges the way Elden Ring does. Nope, it's all one big map. Bonus points for the DLC, which adds a ton of content, and some of the most challenging fights in the series. Cynthia finally has some competition in that department. I'd say this game has the second-best DLC / postgame in the series, beating out ORAS's Episode Delta and the Sword/Shield DLCs. That said, there's one game that has it beat, still to come.
#5. Pokemon Platinum (Gen 4) - The first of the "Big Four" that encompassed the second half of Gen 4 and all of Gen 5, this was the start of four games in a row where they knocked it out of the park. As a result, these four will dominate the Top 5. Platinum is a terrific game that has just the right level of challenge. Wins in this game feel like accomplishments, which is rare for this series, and the final boss Cynthia is debatably the toughest opponent in the series. The postgame kinda leaves something to be desired, continuing a lot of what Emerald started but not adding much else. Why wasn't there a fight with Charon at the end? Regardless, this is easily the best way to play Gen 4. I mean it isn't even a competition; the other two ways are at the bottom of the list.
#4. Pokemon Black / White (Gen 5) - While Platinum has just the right level of challenge, the Gen 5 games are a step up in that department. These games are actually tough! You actually have to know your Pokemon types and weaknesses and use sound strategy. Beyond that, this is as visually nice as the 2D Pokemon games ever get, and it's far more story-focused than any previous game in the series.
The story here could hold up against a lot of other RPGs, which isn't usually something I can say about a Pokemon game. It explores interesting, previously-ignored concepts and elements of the Pokemon world. For example, the inherent unethical nature of Poke-battling and so forth. Problem is, it's mostly the bad guys raising these ethical questions, which undercuts them from getting the amount of thought they probably should. Speaking of the bad guys, this gen has the best set of villains in the series: Team Plasma, led by Ghetsis and N, is probably the most interesting of the Teams in this series. Ghetsis is the big evil kingpin, while N is a much more complicated character, a Pokemon prodigy who serves as a counterpart to your protagonist.
Personally, I felt like this game actually had way too much story, and at times it dragged. There were long spans between gyms, for example, and it often felt like I wasn't making much progress. Still, for being the nicest-looking 2D Pokemon generation, having a strong story / characters, and having actual challenging battles, this game gets very high marks from me.
#3. Pokemon FireRed / LeafGreen (Gen 1 Remake) - This Game Boy Advance gem is the only thing to interrupt the dominance of the Big Four on the DS. Right after Gen 3, when nostalgia for Gen 1 was kicking in, they dropped this aptly-timed masterpiece. Adds the option to play as a girl (Leaf, the tri-tagonist of Gen 1 that wasn't in the games until now) and brings Kanto to life with a colorful and animated world. Iconic characters, iconic 'mons, and iconic gameplay are all at the heart of this game, refined and sharpened to make it possibly the most pure - if low-tech - Pokemon experience out there.
I gave the Gen 1 games pretty low rankings on this list, and a lot of that was because this game obsoletes every other way to experience Kanto. It has all of the nostalgia and none of the bugs, glitches, or poor AI. The best version of the most nostalgic generation. It's short, too; something one can just revisit every few years and have a blast every time. There aren't as many typings as later games in the series, and you won't find any complex battles here, but it's very much a "simple is better" sort of thing. Also, it adds a postgame island chain with some new stuff to do. It's just a very respectable game all around.
#2. Pokemon HeartGold / SoulSilver (Gen 2 Remake) - Takes everything Platinum does right, and Gen 4's general engine, and gives all of that to the far-superior Gen 2. The results are spectacular, going well beyond even FireRed/LeafGreen. It adds the physical/special move split introduced in Gen 4, which makes Gen 2 far more balanced and interesting. For the first time in the series (outside of Yellow and Pikachu), you can have a Pokemon walk alongside you. The two legendaries are both available regardless of version, and are now integrated into the story. The slow level curve that plagued the early versions of Gen 2 is less of an issue / more smoothed-out now (it's still an issue, though).
The Kanto "postgame" (really, it's the third act) is still awesome. Maybe the best thing about this game is that it's the first time since Crystal that you could have every Pokemon in the series in your collection inside of one game. Out of the 493 Pokemon available in Gens 1-4, you could catch 375 of them natively in this game (all of Gen 1 + 2, and a lot of 3 + 4), then add the other 118 via trades from, say, Platinum and Emerald. The best way to play Gen 2, which is widely considered the best generation by the fanbase. It sold a lot better than my #1 pick (nearly twice as many copies) and would probably get that spot on most lists.
---
------
----------
---------------
And now, Professor Sonia from Gen 8 presents...
#1. Pokemon Black 2 / White 2 (Gen 5) - Gen 5 is the only one to get a true sequel as a second game, rather than just a new version. This was a somewhat unsung game that didn't sell well; it sold around 8 million copies which is in the doldrums (for this series) with Platinum. They made this more of a traditional Pokemon game after the first Gen 5 game went in a more story-based direction. You've got the eight gyms and a focus on those rather than on telling a sweeping story, and everything old is new again. Except this is probably the best iteration of this format that they ever did. They took everything that worked about HG/SS, plus the world from B/W, and made a game with no weaknesses.
Team Plasma returns and their storyline does continue, even if it isn't as dominant, with Ghetsis continuing to be perhaps the series' most chilling antagonist - and N perhaps its most interesting character. Most notably, while Black/White only let you explore the eastern side of Unova's map, the sequel opens up the entire region. It also adds a ton of new Pokemon to the region, including many from earlier gens, allowing for a lot more party and type diversity than the first Gen 5 game did.
This also has the best postgame in the series, adding tons of content, including gym leader rematches from all across the series. No other game does anything like this. It culminates with a Pokemon World Tournament where you fight all of the series' Pokemon Champions up to this point as postgame superbosses. Yes, all of them, with Cynthia and Ash being the strongest of course. This is one game that gives you miles of value, and actual reasons to level your party into the upper reaches of the level cap range (some of the postgame superbosses have parties as high as level 90).
It's a shame so many players missed out on this game, and there's one big reason for that - the 3DS was out by this point and people were waiting for the series to jump to that system. This got released instead, and was likely viewed as little more than a stopgap while they worked on X/Y on the 3DS (which sold exponentially better, despite being a much worse game).
More likely than not, there was some confusion about what Black/White 2 actually were, and a lot of folks probably assumed these were just deluxe versions of the previous games like the series usually does. Combine that with the antiquated system and it didn't get much of a shot. Too bad, because this ended up being the pinnacle of 2D Pokemon games and probably the best the series has ever been. Probably the only Pokemon game you can play for 100 hours without running out of things to do, or get to level 100 and have it serve a purpose.
When it comes to fan polls on this series, it's pretty clear that nostalgia rules everything. The 2D generations definitely have the advantage, but it's really the first three that have the good memories and vibes locked in with the playerbase. We've gotten a lot of improvements since then, though, if we're looking at it objectively.



.jpg)





.jpg)
















No comments:
Post a Comment