Sunday, November 15, 2026

Pokemon Platinum (Generation 4), Part 9 - Elite Four and Cynthia


Today: THE HARDEST FIGHT IN THE SERIES.


Final team, after all the adjustments and tweaks. I forgot to use my Rock Candies (had 5, I think)...not sure who I should have even used them for, though. Everyone has their final move (at least, their final move that I'll actually use) and a suitable item equipped. Giving the candies to Nipple H probably would have been the best move, actually, since he has to stay standing long enough, and be quick enough, to land Ice Beam on Cynthia's Garchomp. Possibly twice. That's critical. It's the Game 7 buzzer-beater of this game.

In the remake I need to make sure to get a good Ice-type for this job, because leaving it to a Water-type doesn't have me brimming with confidence. Weavile or Frostlass, probably.

The crucial Ice Beam, plus Hydro Pump. Also some Steel and Flying coverage though I don't think those will factor in. NeverMeltIce is his equipped item and that'll give me...20%? more damage on Ice Beam, which doesn't make up for the 50% bonus I'd get from having an actual strong Ice-type use it, but it might be enough.

Rapidash is here for Fire-type coverage and nothing else. He can deal with Cynthia's Roserade and quite a few of the Elite Four 'mons. Razor Claw increases critical hit rate, which will be good for Flamethrower spam. I think the other two moves are slightly stronger than Flamethrower, but Fire Blast misses a lot and Flare Blitz has a ton of recoil. The damage difference is negligible, Flamethrower gets it done.

Giratina got my Earthquake TM, which was a mistake, it should have gone to Garchomp (and will in the remake). Giratina is Dragon/Ghost type, and Shadow Force will be super useful on the Elite Four. Thunder is about all I have for Elec-type coverage and it misses a lot, so that's unfortunate. Soft Sand is a 20% boost to Ground-type, aka Earthquake, which combined with Giratina's high survivability should allow it to take down a bunch of endgame 'mons that are weak to Ground.

Garchomp is Dragon/Ground and SHOULD be on Earthquake OHKO duty in these fights. Instead it's there as sort of a neutral stand-in since Dragon-type is essentially neutral to everyone. Also good if I need a Dark move, though Giratina has Ghost-type covered really well. This is a bit of a waste of a Garchomp, but it was STILL worth leveling it up because it can fill a number of roles. Just not as well as the specialized 'mons. Dragon Fang, you guessed it, boosts the Dragon-type moves.

Gardevoir is another one that I might not get too much use out of in this finale. It's got Elec and Grass coverage (my only Grass coverage) and a Mind Plate boosted Psychic. So it's here to fill in some gaps. Though with it being a lower level than the others, it has questionable survival. Still, it might be able to take down a foe weak to Grass or Elec here and there, saving me from having Giratina taking unnecessary damage before I need to bring it out. Shock Wave is weaker than Thunder but it also misses a lot less.

Staraptor, which like Garchomp was a bit of a late addition to the team, has totally earned his stripes. Brave Bird is the best Flying-type move, but it's an extremely situational type. Most of why he's here is Close Combat, which, with Fist Plate boosting it, can obliterate a bunch of the endgame 'mons even with his level being a little lower.

Before I can even fight the Elite Four, I have to do one final battle with the rival. He isn't the champion this time, but he DOES have six 'mons...which is more than any other fight in the game besides the champion.

If I'd fought him before I did my huge leveling spree in the last episode, he would have been a pretty big challenge because I wouldn't have been able to outspeed him with everyone at a median level of 43-45. Now, with everyone at a median level of 55-57, I can outspeed him all around. Rapidash easily trounces his starter.

Much like the rest of the fights with him, his final 'mon isn't his starter, but rather his own Rapidash. He must have also seen the huge value in this 'mon in this Fire-type deficient generation.

Staraptor unleashes the ultimate Flying-type move! ...not sure what we're looking at here!

BUT WAIT! This time around, Rapidash isn't his final 'mon. He's got this BIG AMERICAN BEEFY BOI to close things out.

Bring out the Garchomp!

Get outta here, Nolan! I can't hear your dialogue over the sound in your movies!

::loud movie trailer blasts as he walks out::

BWAAAAAWWW

Elite Four time. First up is AY AY RON. These rooms give you a good idea of what type you're dealing with.

AY AY RON is the master of....Grass-type? Well, everything gives that impression, but nope, he's actually...

...JESUS, WHAT IS THAT?

.....he's the master of Bug-Types. This fight is barely worth a mention, because Staraptor basically sweeps his entire team with Brave Bird. Most of that damage taken is Brave Bird recoil damage.

Bertha is all about Ground and Rock types. And surprisingly, she isn't a giant woman.

Whiscash snuck in there, which is an opportunity for Gardevoir to make use of the Grass-type move I brought. Dr. Wily will not be pleased.

Giratina gets brought out to deal with the rest of her team, and mops up without much issue.

Rhyperior is basically the "boss" here, though it doesn't matter. Giratina isn't totally OP, but it's definitely my strongest overall 'mon. I'll have to do without it in the remake.

She's more scientist than anything else. Here they are normalizing the name Bertha.

Next up is Flint, master of...not sure. Steel, maybe? Water? Probably Water

A woman just needs some foreplay, sir.

Flint is really into Dawn. He's got an array of Fire-types. In the original Diamond/Pearl there were only like two Fire-types in the entire game, so he had those two and then a bunch of non-Fire 'mons to fill out his team. It was weird. Well, this version fixes that just by making more Fire-types available.

I wasn't able to find an Eevee during the game and that's a bummer. Not sure if it's even accessible before the postgame. The foes sure have them though, which at least adds more variety to fights like this. Heck, just adding Eevee and its forms to Platinum added a new 'mon to a bunch of types right there.

Here's the big brother of that butt-foreheaded 'mon earlier. He's got an arm cannon! EVERYBODY GET DOWN!

Giratina pretty much sweeps this entire fight with Earthquake, after handling the majority of the previous fight as well. I just need to be careful to manage my moves and not run out of the strongest attacks. Which means holding back Earthquake against Bertha and going more for Dragon Claw.

Flint is really, really into Dawn.

I switch Giratina's item from Ground-boost to Ghost-boost for the next fight, which is...

...the master of Psychic. That type once reigned supreme, and was unstoppable in Gen 1. Now, I barely ever see it anymore. Well, this guy is bringing it back.

I lucked out, because Giratina's Ghost-type attack can OHKO pretty much all of this guy's 'mons. I've been packing that heat in case I ran into any tough Psychic-type foes, and had to wait until this moment to make any use of it. However...

...the first one up is more a job for Fire-types, which gets Rapidash some last-minute EXP.

The Michael Jordan of Gen 1. His era of dominance is long gone. It's awesome that he's here though. They threw him in to pay homage to the greats.

It's interesting how Platinum contains all of the Gen 1 and 3 Pokémon as well, anything that had a GBA version is included. That's a lot to fit on a DS cart. Enemy trainers can make use of the pre-Sinnoh 'mons, but you can't catch them in the wild, and are limited to the Sinnoh 'mons yourself until after the game is finished. Then in the postgame you can catch 'mons from the other two gens, or transfer them over I suppose. It's too bad they don't have all three gens in the main game, but if they did, people would probably ignore the new Sinnoh 'mons and only use their favorites from the old gens. So I get why it's all locked to postgame.

What about Johto, though? Gen 2's missing from this equation. I guess the idea there was that with the Gen 2 remake being the next thing to develop after this, it would be where Gen 2 'mons would get added. So in theory by the end of those games you'd be able to trade everything from this game over and have all four gens completed (and keep that rolling until the series left the DS/3DS ecosystem after Gen 7)

As for Alakazam, our hero HOSES HIM DOWN.

Giratina comes in for the last several 'mons and sweeps them with Shadow Force, which is a "disappear for one turn and then hit hard on the second" like Fly. With Ghost-type boosted, this move wrecks. This is probably the second-hardest fight in the game and I just trivialized it with Giratina and this move. I won't be able to do that in the remake, where Lucian is more powerful and Giratina isn't an option.

Giratina learns its final move, Earth Power. This seems like it's basically a weaker version of Earthquake. Probably a little more accurate while doing less damage. Earthquake is accurate enough and has me covered, so I pass on Earth Power. Not to mention that Earthquake is an AOE, so it absolutely destroys double battles. Just need to make sure to pair Giratina up with Staraptor, who floats above the quake, since it hits your ally as well.

That said, if I had saved the Earthquake TM for Garchomp like I should have in retrospect, then this would be a big moment for Giratina because it would give me effectively a second Ground-user for the final battle. Which would definitely help.

Cynthia, the hardest fight in this game, and the hardest final boss in the entire Pokémon series. Some even say the hardest fight in general in the entire series. Outside of postgame uberboss Red at the end of Gen 2, and possibly AI Sada at the end of Gen 9, I can't think of anything else that might contest Cynthia's status at the top of the series pyramid.

THIS IS IT.

Another six-on-six, and it's a good thing I got rid of the HM mules before this. What would be really interesting is if I were going in blind and getting flattened by this team. However, I'm not, I'm prepared. So we'll have to go without the epic rite of passage that is everyone's first battle with Cynthia. No, I did all of that back when Gen 4 first dropped in 2006, so the surprise/shock of this absolute wall of a final boss already played out then. Suffice to say... a player who isn't expecting it is going to find themselves in a brutal fight.

First up on her veritable All-Star Team of 'mons: Spiritomb, which has zero weaknesses in Gen 4. That's right, zero weaknesses. It's the only 'mon in Sinnoh with no weaknesses, because its one weakness Fairy type doesn't exist yet.

I believed in Staraptor, despite its lower level, and I wasn't disappointed. This thing is a BEAST with Close Combat, despite not even being a Fighting-type, and eliminates the need to have one. It was a close fight, regardless.

Next up is Togekiss. This is a bit of a curveball because she has something different in Diamond/Pearl (meaning I'll have to fight something else in the remake, which follows those games). That...actually will be a surprise because I don't remember what it was.

Togekiss has a bunch of weaknesses, but nothing particularly major, and Gardevoir is at a level disadvantage. I used Electric-type attacks to bring this one down, and Gardevoir didn't make it (Giratina had to finish the job, but wasn't particularly weakened by it).

And now...it's Garchomp time. Debatably Cynthia's ace, this thing is fast and powerful, and can OHKO an entire team one by one if it outspeeds everyone and nothing has the HP to withstand it. I just need for my Garchomp to soften up hers so that Nipple H can switch in and land an Ice Beam for the kill.

.....and my Garchomp gets dropped immediately. By a Ground move. Despite being Ground-type. Unbelievable. This is particularly rattling, after all the work I put into building it up. No softening up, so I have to just hope one Ice Beam is enough for the OHKO. With Nipple H not being Ice-type, it's doubtful.

Our hopes and dreams now lie with Nipple H and the Ice Beam. But sure enough, Garchomp outspeeds me again. Of course it does. It then pastes me with Earthquake:

...........

.........................................

Oh My God. One HP left. ONE HP LEFT.

I retaliate with the Ice Beam. Either this gets an OHKO, or I probably lose the fight, because she'll full heal on the next turn and I have nothing else able to take down Garchomp.

And...it was enough. Man, all of my over preparation, which really was overkill because I rolled the Elite Four....and I still barely scraped past this. If I'd been one level lower on Empoleon, it would have been a loss. Whether I got chain-OHKO'd or not was entirely dependent on one level. And nope, it wasn't a special ability like Endure that caused survival with 1 HP here, it was being juuuust strong enough.

Never doubt the difference that 1 HP can make.

If any Pokemon ever earned any EXP points, it's this shot right here.

Hard to believe that this fight is only half over. The murderer's row continues, and I'm also basically down to two of my 'mons. Luckily, I have type weaknesses for the remaining three covered, and have a couple of low health 'mons I can switch in for healing or reviving purposes if necessary.

Giratina quickly mops up Lucario with Earthquake - which is key because if you don't take out Lucario immediately, it goes on an OHKO rampage. You've got two turns of it buffing first, and then it's essentially a game over.

Then, her OTHER ace shows up. Milotic is almost as bad as Garchomp. It isn't an OHKO fest, but it is an absolute tank and strong against almost everything. For this one I need to break out Electric, which means...

...using Thunder, with its high miss rate. It took several shots, between the misses, and it not being an OHKO. I believe she healed here, as well. So yeah, a bunch of Thunders. Luckily Giratina was strong enough to survive until I could heal between every couple of Thunders. If I'd been using Gardevoir for this (who also has an Elec move) I wouldn't have lasted long.

That leaves Roserade...who is a formidable foe, but I've got a Fire-type burning a hole in my pocket here. This one's over. NOBODY PUTS DAWN IN A CORNER!

BANG-ZOOOOM!!

Fight over. The greatest battle in the series.

KO COUNT:
Staraptor - 1
Gardevoir - 0
Garchomp - 0
Empoleon - 1 (the most important one)
Giratina - 3
Rapidash - 1

Fight MVP: Empoleon, but Giratina certainly led on points.

Cynthia takes defeat graciously. It's definitely better to have her as an ally than an enemy. No other final boss in this series makes this kind of impression. This game goes hard with opponents: There's a villain, a rival, AND a champion and none of them overlap.

Cynthia was the hardest fight in the game, but honorable mentions need to go to Lucian and the final Cyrus fight. All three were very difficult, probably worse than anything in Gen 3. Not sure if that Cyrus fight will even be in the remake, but the other two will be even more difficult there.

I'd say Gen 4 is pretty solidly the most difficult Pokemon generation. The two Gen 5 games are also a bit tough... and then the series difficulty flies off a cliff after that, IIRC. Gen 9 brings it back, but mostly in the postgame.

Say bye to this team here, because most of them won't make it onto my team in the remake. Giratina doesn't exist and Empoleon won't be my starter, so even the two MVPs won't make it.

Staraptor and Garchomp...will return.

What's next? Well, the terrible Gen 4 remake, obviously. Also going to finally replay the Gen 2 and 3 remakes. Which are debatably some of the greatest games in the series.

Credits roll. So final thoughts on Platinum? It's without a doubt the definitive version of Gen 4. With the other generations, usually an argument can be made. What's the definitive version, the deluxe or the remake?

The definitive version question is probably most difficult in Gen 3 with Emerald vs ORAS. I don't know how I'd answer that one...yet. Emerald feels like it was easily the best "deluxe" version they've made yet, combining the storylines of the two predecessor games and functionally making them obsolete. While ORAS is just a fundamentally solid leap to 3D that makes that world come alive.

As far as the first two gens: FRLG vs Yellow vs Let's Go, and HGSS vs Crystal, I think they're easier to pick a definitive version on (FRLG, HGSS). The remakes blow away the originals, even the deluxe versions. Gen 3's definitive version, on the other hand, really depends on the player. Personally I think I'd go with ORAS over Emerald for one main reason: The shared party EXP. Also the 3D visuals are a lot nicer to look at.

Well, like the first two gens, Gen 4 is an easy one to answer...and the only one that I'd definitely give to the deluxe version. Platinum utterly demolishes the Switch remakes in every way and it isn't even close. THIS is the definitive version of Gen 4, and there's a big gulf between it and the predecessor games. It's too bad Platinum sold fairly poorly (worse than any main series game up to this point, I believe) because it's one of the best in the series and the beginning of a bit of a series renaissance.

Even if one played Diamond/Pearl in the past and disliked how slow and dull they were, this game rights the wrongs of the past and straightens out a Gen 4 that really should have been great from the get go. Going right from this into the Gen 2 remakes and the Gen 5 games was a magical four year span back in the day, and they're four games well worth a revisit even today.

No comments:

Post a Comment